Skip to content
PagkainPinoy
Menu
← Cooking Guides

Ingredients & Substitutions

Self-Raising Flour in Puto? Check What Is Already in the Bag

Avoid doubling raising agents, distinguish UK and US flour formulations, and decide when a puto recipe needs its original plain flour.

In this article

Do not replace the plain flour in a puto recipe with self-raising flour and automatically retain all its baking powder. The bag already contains raising agents. The useful question is whether its formulation matches the recipe, including any added salt. When you cannot establish that match, use the original flour or choose a recipe written for the bag you have. Source 1

A similar name can hide a different blend

Nigella’s recipe team explains that UK self-raising flour normally has no added salt, while US self-rising flour commonly includes it. That difference matters when a Filipino recipe travels with you abroad or when an imported bag replaces a familiar local one. An instruction to omit the recipe’s salt may suit one flour and be wrong for another. Source 2

Read the ingredient panel
ExampleWhat is already included
King Arthur self-rising flourWheat flour with baking powder and salt; its substitution guidance is written around its own concentrated raising agent. Source 1
Doves Farm self-raising white flourWheat flour with monocalcium phosphate and sodium bicarbonate; the ingredient list does not separately include salt. Source 3

On the Doves Farm label, the chemical names identify the raising agents even though the words baking powder are not used. Its nutrition panel also reports salt, but that is not a substitute for reading the ingredient list when comparing formulations. Keep the original bag until you have used the flour; a plain container marked only flour loses information you need for the next batch. Source 3

Do not remove every raising ingredient at once

Baking soda listed separately in a recipe needs its own decision. Nigella advises including it when the recipe specifically calls for it alongside self-raising flour. You cannot assume that the presence of one raising system automatically replaces another. Cross out an ingredient only when the recipe author or flour maker’s applicable conversion tells you to do so. Source 2

Flour strength can change too. King Arthur describes its self-rising flour as lower in protein than its all-purpose flour. Those are figures for those products, not fixed values for every flour sold under the same names. Matching the amount of baking powder alone does not guarantee that a different bag will produce the same crumb. Source 1

Make a decision before mixing the batter

  1. Identify the exact flour in your chosen puto recipe. If it calls for rice flour, a bag of self-raising wheat flour is a different ingredient, not a renamed equivalent.
  2. Read the replacement bag for wheat type, raising agents and added salt. Photograph the complete ingredient list if the flour is being transferred to a container.
  3. Look for a conversion that applies to that recipe and that flour. If either remains uncertain, keep the written formula and obtain its specified flour.
  4. Save any successful adapted recipe with the brand and product name. A note that merely says self-raising leaves the next baker to guess.

For a family merienda, experimentation can be worthwhile when you can keep clear notes. For a large celebration batch, using a known formula is the more dependable choice. The convenience of a premixed flour comes from knowing what has already been mixed into it.

Sources

  1. How to substitute self-rising flour for all-purpose flour (and vice versa!)King Arthur BakingChecked 2026-11-03
    Back to reading
    All 4 references1 2 3 4
  2. Self-Rising Flour SubstitutionNigella LawsonChecked 2026-11-03
    Back to reading
    All 2 references1 2
  3. Organic Self Raising White Flour 1kgDoves FarmChecked 2026-11-03
    Back to reading
    All 3 references1 2 3